Top 25 Under 25

April 14, 2008
We'll be publishing Top 25 Under 25 lists every other week this season. Keep checking back!
No.   Player   Pos.   Comments   Age   Org   Lvl
1   Prince Fielder   1B   Youngest player ever to hit 50 HR in a season; also had great '07 walk rate (15.8%)   23.9   MIL   MLB
2   Miguel Cabrera   3B   New $153 Millionaire hit .313/.388/.542 through his first five full seasons in the majors   24.9   DET   MLB
3   Hanley Ramirez   SS   Ranked 11th in MLB in wOBA last year (.398), .048 point jump in IsoP from '06 to '07   24.3   FLA   MLB
4   Jose Reyes   SS   Increased walk rate by 4.1% in '07; better defender than Ramirez, not as much power   24.8   NYM   MLB
5   Joe Mauer   C   Showed that he's a special hitter in '06 (.362 wOBA); we think he'll rebound in 2008   24.9   MIN   MLB
6   Felix Hernandez   RHP   GB pitcher with good K% (20.4 in '07), BB% (6.6); things will click for him eventually   22.0   SEA   MLB
7   Ryan Braun   LF   .310 IsoP was 5th in MLB last season -- behind Carlos Pena, A-Rod, Fielder, Howard   24.4   MIL   MLB
8   Cole Hamels   LHP   Has been a No. 2 starter for 300.0+ innings; 23.8% K, 5.8% BB last year; ace potential   24.2   PHI   MLB
9   Justin Upton   RF   14 months younger than any player in the bigs; .294/.379/.502 in MiLB/MLB last year   20.6   ARI   MLB
10   Yovani Gallardo   RHP   Fourty more innings like he had last year (MLB) and he's an ace: 3.35 FIP and 21.7% K   22.1   MIL   MLB
11   Tim Lincecum   RHP   His high walk rate (10.6% in MLB) is the only thing keeping him from becoming a No. 1   23.8   SF   MLB
12   Jay Bruce   CF   Coming off amazing 2007 (.319/.375/.587, A+/AA/AAA); still youngest player in AAA   21.0   CIN   AAA
13   Colby Rasmus   CF   Could be a 35+ HR talent in CF; BB% (12.6 in '07) helps OBP, pull-approach hurts BA   21.6   STL   AA
14   B.J. Upton   CF   High K% (25.6 since '06) has us wondering how much he can build upon '07 success   23.6   TB   MLB
15   Scott Kazmir   LHP   Mounting injury history is why he's below Hernandez, Hamels here; 26.9% K since '06   24.2   TB   MLB
16   Ryan Zimmerman   3B   Moving out of difficult home park, wrist surgically repaired last offseason; excellent D   23.5   WAS   MLB
17   Billy Butler   1B   3rd-youngest player in the bigs; more a 2B hitter than HR hitter now; power will come   21.9   KC   MLB
18   Evan Longoria   3B   Solid power hitter who can draw a walk; .299/.402/.520 between AA/AAA last year   22.4   TB   AAA
19   Clay Buchholz   RHP   32.7% K last season, 7.6% BB, and a big league No-No; could be a No. 2 starter in '08   23.6   BOS   MLB
20   Alex Gordon   3B   Off to good start in 2008 after his '07 belly flop (.311 wOBA); .434 wOBA in AA ('06)   24.1   KC   AAA
21   Joba Chamberlain   RHP   Owned MLB hitters over 24.0 IP in '07 (1.90 FIP, 37.4% K); what can he do as a SP?   22.5   NYY   MLB
22   Fausto Carmona   RHP   Average No. 2 starter in first full MLB season; 66% GB put him among game's leaders   24.3   CLE   MLB
23   Matt Cain   RHP   Will need lower BB% (10.3) to become an ace; strong K% (19.6) and GB% (40) in '07   23.5   SF   MLB
24   Brian McCann   C   Dealt with some nagging injuries last season; got hot in July/August; .386 wOBA in '06   24.1   ATL   MLB
25   Chris Young   CF   Sub-.300 OBP is a significant chink in his armor; extreme-pull-hitter has 35+ HR power   24.6   ARI   MLB
Honorable Mentions: Phil Hughes, Clayton Kershaw, Johnny Cueto, Chad Billingsley, Francisco Liriano, and Troy Tulowitzki.        
<<< Discuss these rankings                
* Our rankings are a snapshot of a player's potential and the odds that he'll recognize it            
** Ages are as of April 14th, 2008.            
*** Lvl is the highest level where the player has 100 PA/TBF            


































































































PPr





 

Prince Fielder is taking away from Miguel Cabrera and Joe Mauer's thunder by coming in No. 1 on our Top 25 Under 25 in-season debut. While the big first baseman won't turn 25 until May of 2009, Cabrera and Mauer turn 25 later this week. We'll be updating our Top 25 Under 25 every other week for the remainder of the regular season. But check back every week because we'll be publishing Top 25 Prospect lists in between.

 

Enjoy,

Adam Foster
Project Prospect Founder
adamf@projectprospect.com