Top 50 Hitters Under 25

by Project Prospect
March 9, 2009
Enjoy lists like this? Want to help us improve our product? Check out Ticket City for great values on sports tickets.

 

All Positions: C / 1B / 2B / SS / 3B / CF / OF / P

Top 50 Hitters Under the age of 25
No.   Player   Pos.   Comments   Age   Org   Lvl
1   Hanley Ramirez   SS   Followed .400 wOBA in '07 with .394 rate in '08; much improved patience (7.4% BB vs. 13.3%)   24.8   FLA   MLB
2   B.J. Upton   CF   Breakout alert: huge postseason, shoulder repaired, K% down 7.2 ('07 to '08) and BB% up 3.3   24.1   TB   MLB
3   Justin Upton   RF   .347 wOBA in bigs as 21-year-old; low contact (.250 AVG, 29.0% K), great discipline (12.9%)    21.1   ARI   MLB
4   Ryan Braun   LF   Followed .417 rookie wOBA w/ .369 in '08; has power (.268 IsoP), lacks patience (6.3% BB)   24.9   MIL   MLB
5   Nick Markakis   RF   wOBA has gone from .345 to .362 to .388 in 3 MLB years; 14.3% BB ('08), 8.6 ('07), 7.9 ('06)   24.9   BAL   MLB
6   Prince Fielder   1B   Didn't live up to '07 standards (.404 wOBA) in '08 (.358); patience still there though (12.1% BB)    24.4   MIL   MLB
7   Brian McCann   C   Returned to form (.378 wOBA) after slow season in '07 (.319); 43.1% XBH, 10.6% BB rates   24.6   ATL   MLB
8   Evan Longoria   3B   Offensively, he was 08's Ryan Braun -- less power and speed, more walks and better glove   23.0   TB   MLB
9   Matt Wieters   C   Put up videogame-esque .355/.454/.600 line between A+, AA; .918 OPS (33 AB) in AFL   22.4   BAL   AA
10   Jay Bruce   RF   Solid .330 wOBA as rookie; like Upton, had trouble making contact (.254 AVG, 24.3% K)   21.5   CIN   MLB
11   Elijah Dukes   RF   Went .264/.386/.478 in 334 MLB PA in '08; solid power (.214 IsoP), great patience (15.0%)   24.3   WAS   MLB
12   Matt Kemp   CF/RF   Went .291/.340/.460 in 1st full MLB season (655 PA); BB, K rates both up slightly from '07   24.1   LAD   MLB
13   Ryan Zimmerman   3B   Similar offensive production to Gordon (.345 wOBA in 1932 career PA), much better defense   24.0   WAS   MLB
14   Chris Davis   1B/3B   .369 wOBA in 317 MLB PA; lack of discipline (6.3% BB), high K's (27.8%) causes for concern   22.6   TEX   MLB
15   Troy Tulowitzki   SS   Injuries, struggles made for an '08 season Tulo may like to forget: .310 wOBA vs. .360 in '07   24.0   COL   MLB
16   Cameron Maybin   CF   Nearly replicated A+ (.406 wOBA) numbers in AA (.381); still K'd a ton (26.9%); .179 IsoP   21.5   FLA   MLB
17   Alex Gordon   3B/1B   Improved contact rate slightly from '07 to '08 + walk rate up 4.8% on his way to a .338 wOBA   24.7   KC   MLB
18   Colby Rasmus   CF   After posting .397 wOBA in AA in '07, fell to .324 in AAA in '08; missed time w/ sprained knee   22.2   STL   AAA
19   Dexter Fowler   CF   Olympian had breakout year: career-best .401 wOBA; lots of BBs (12.9%), K's down (17.6%)   22.6   COL   MLB
20   Lastings Milledge   CF   Seems like he's been around forever, but '08 was 1st full MLB season: .320 wOBA, .134 IsoP   23.5   WAS   MLB
21   Billy Butler   1B/DH   Inverted BB, K %'s in AAA (12.2%, 6.1%), bigs (6.9%, 11.9%); .319 wOBA in 578 MLB PA   22.5   KC   MLB
22   Delmon Young   LF   Wonder if Minnesota would like Garza back? Young had .319 wOBA, .115 IsoP last season   23.1   MIN   MLB
23   Travis Snider   LF/DH   .361 wOBA across 4 levels in '08; lots of power, BB's, K's; could see regular time in bigs in '09   20.7   TOR   MLB
24   Daric Barton   1B   Disappointed in 1st full MLB season (.296 wOBA); lots of walks, good LD%, mainly gap power   23.2   OAK   MLB
25   Jeremy Hermida   RF   After posting .373 wOBA in '07, fell to .315 in '08; contact rates, power down significantly   24.7   FLA   MLB
26   Adam Jones   CF   After putting up .409 wOBA in AAA ('07), went .309 w/ Orioles in '08; IsoP cut in half; great D   23.2   BAL   MLB
27   Travis Buck   RF   Slowed by post-concussion woes (.311 wOBA in bigs); fighting for starting RF slot in OAK   24.9   OAK   MLB
28   Jason Heyward   RF   6-foot-4, 220-pounder had .377 wOBA, 9.7% BB, not too many K's (14.7%) last year in Low-A   19.2   ATL   A+
29   Pedro Alvarez   3B   High upside hitter w/ power + patience; missed time in '08 (contract disputes/broken hamate)   21.7   PIT   NCAA
30   James Loney   1B   After .385 wOBA in '07, dropped to .331 in '08; similar LD (23, 20%), lower BABIP (.352, .320)   24.4   LAD   MLB
31   Mike Moustakas   3B   Tale of two halves in '08; pre all-star: .228/.285/.386, post all-star: .321/.392/.557; .343 wOBA    20.1   KC   A
32   Matt LaPorta   RF/LF   Went .279/.386/.539 ('08); plenty of power (.260 IsoP), 11.3% BB; slowed once traded to Tribe   23.8   CLE   AA
33   Jordan Schafer   CF   HGH use costed him 50 games; good power (.202 IsoP), good BB (14.0%), bad K's (25.2%)   22.1   ATL   AA
34   Dioner Navarro   C   Production slowed after All-Star Break (.785 OPS vs. .715); .333 wOBA, .112 IsoP overall   24.7   TB   MLB
35   Justin Smoak   1B   No. 11 overall pick had .372 wOBA (62 PA) in Low-A; .450 wOBA, 40% XBH in 48 AFL PA    21.9   TEX   A
36   Lars Anderson   1B   All he did was follow .398 wOBA showing in Cal League with .415 wOBA in Eastern League   21.1   BOS   AA
37   Mike Stanton   RF/CF   Put up crazy .318 IsoP in 1st full pro season (39 HR in 540 PA), but tons of K's, too (28.3%)   18.9   FLA   A
38   Carlos Gomez   CF   7th youngest hitter in MLB last season; exceptional D; could be an average hitter in his prime   22.9   MIN   MLB
39   Eric Hosmer   1B   No. 3 overall pick brings advanced approach to the plate for a high schooler; some power, too    19.0   KC   R
40   Buster Posey   C   Selected No. 5 overall after great Jr. season; not much power in Hawaii: .338/.405/.392 (84 PA)   21.6   SF   SS
41   Carlos Santana   C/DH   Call it a breakout: went .326/.431/.568 in '08 after .223/.318/.370 showing in '07; 16.5% BB   22.5   CLE   A+
42   Yonder Alonso   1B   No. 7 overall pick sported a .308/.419/.510 line (124 PA) in HWB; both power, patience    21.5   CIN   A+
43   Logan Morrison   1B   As if his .386 wOBA in the Florida State League hasn’t impressive, he was .484 in the AFL   21.1   FLA   A+
44   Tim Beckham   SS   No. 1 overall pick in June's draft had .287 wOBA in 189 PA; low contact: 21.7% K, .251 AVG   18.7   TB   R
45   Gordon Beckham   SS/2B   This Beckham had more success in pro debut: No. 8 pick went .394/.468/.652 in AFL (78 PA)   22.1   CHW   A
46   Fernando Martinez   CF/LF   Wasn't overmatched as youngest AA player (.332 wOBA); IsoP up from .106 ('07) to .145 ('08)   20.0   NYM   AA
47   Denard Span   CF   Vision corrected, career catipulted; 02's 20th overall pick put up .355 wOBA in 1st MLB season   24.6   MIN   MLB
48   Andrew McCutchen   CF   Still not much power (.115 IsoP); finding ways on base: 11.5% BB rate best since rookie ball   22.0   PIT   AAA
49   Pablo Sandoval   C/1B   Went .350/.394/.578 (485 PA) between A+, AA, then .345/.357/.490 (154 PA) in majors    22.2   SF   MLB
50   Asdrubal Cabrera   2B/SS   Had his share of rookie struggles (.310 wOBA), but finished strong: .425 in Sept. (91 PA)   22.9   CLE   MLB
Honorables: Jose Lopez (2B), Ian Stewart (3B), Blake DeWitt (2B), Brandon Wood (LAA), Brett Wallace (STL), and Dustin Ackley (UNC).    
* Our rankings combine a player's ceiling with the odds that he'll reach it and favor recent production            
** Ages are as of November 1st, 2008            
*** Level is the highest level the player has reached            
                         
<<< Discuss these rankings                

 

Questions about this list can be directed toward Adam Foster at adamf@projectprospect.com.